Broadway has long been a stage for storytelling, magic, and dreams. But for decades, representation in leading roles was limited, with many characters traditionally portrayed by white actors. That began to change as trailblazing Black women shattered stereotypes, stepped into iconic roles, and proved that Broadway belongs to everyone.
From fairy-tale princesses to beloved musical heroines, these extraordinary women have left an indelible mark on theater history. Let’s celebrate the groundbreaking achievements of Toni Braxton, Keke Palmer, Brittney Johnson, and Aisha Jackson—four Black actresses who redefined what it means to be a Broadway star.
Toni Braxton: The First Black Belle in Beauty and the Beast
In 1998, Toni Braxton made history when she became the first Black actress to portray Belle in Disney’s Beauty and the Beast on Broadway. Already an established music superstar with multiple Grammy Awards, Braxton’s transition to Broadway was a monumental moment—not just for her career, but for the industry as a whole.
Toni Braxton was the first Black woman to play Belle on Broadway. pic.twitter.com/n0UzXl651i
— Disney Princess Facts (@DPrincess_Facts) June 12, 2021
A Belle Unlike Any Other
Taking on the role of the book-loving, independent Belle was a significant step in diversifying Disney’s Broadway productions. Up until that point, Disney princesses had largely been played by white actresses, reinforcing the industry’s lack of representation. Braxton’s casting challenged these norms and inspired countless young Black girls who finally saw themselves in the role of a beloved Disney heroine.
A Special Touch: A Song Written Just for Her
As a tribute to her involvement, Alan Menken and Tim Rice wrote a brand-new song for Braxton called “A Change in Me.” Initially meant to be a one-time performance exclusive to her run, the song became so beloved that it was permanently added to the musical.
Toni Braxton as Belle on Broadway , the song a “Change in Me” was specifically written for Toni and added in the show after she was casted in this role , and remained in the show following her departure 🔥 pic.twitter.com/8YexFmw9ei
— Prince Jay ✨ (@theprincejay_) September 23, 2024
Braxton’s success as Belle paved the way for more diverse casting in Disney’s Broadway adaptations, proving that talent, not race, should determine who gets to play a princess.
Keke Palmer: The First Black Cinderella on Broadway
In 2014, Keke Palmer made history when she became the first Black actress to play Cinderella in Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella on Broadway. At just 21 years old, the actress, singer, and television personality stepped into the glass slippers and enchanted audiences with her heartfelt performance.
anyways I love Keke Palmer the Original Cinderella on Broadway ✨ pic.twitter.com/fhlQRXnhYU
— Kels 🌸 (@Kelseyummm) August 17, 2021
Following in Brandy’s Footsteps
Palmer’s historic Broadway casting was reminiscent of another trailblazing moment in television history—Brandy Norwood’s portrayal of Cinderella in the 1997 Disney TV movie. Palmer openly credited Brandy as an inspiration, stating:
“I feel like the reason I’m able to do this is definitely because Brandy did it on TV.”
Her performance was a reminder that representation in fairy tales matters. Black girls watching Palmer on stage saw that they, too, could be the princess in their own stories.
A Modern Cinderella Story
Palmer’s Cinderella wasn’t just groundbreaking in terms of race—it was also a refreshing, modern take on the classic tale. She brought charm, warmth, and a contemporary energy to the role, proving that the magic of Broadway is for everyone.
Brittney Johnson: The First Black Glinda in Wicked
For nearly two decades, Wicked has been one of Broadway’s most successful and beloved musicals. Yet, it wasn’t until 2019 that a Black actress took on the role of Glinda the Good Witch—and that honor went to Brittney Johnson.
Always thinking about Brittney Johnson as Glinda! pic.twitter.com/Muz95Bq448
— rachel (@rachellacroixs) November 24, 2024
From Standby to History Maker
Johnson initially joined the cast as a Glinda understudy, later becoming the first Black actress to ever stand by for the role. But on January 10, 2019, history was made when she officially became the first Black actress to play Glinda on Broadway.
Her performance was a significant step forward in diversifying one of Broadway’s most popular shows. Fans of Wicked embraced her with open arms, and her casting proved that roles traditionally played by white actresses could (and should) be given to talented performers of all backgrounds.
Breaking the Bubble for Future Generations
Glinda is known for her signature pink gown, tiara, and the famous line: “It’s good to see me, isn’t it?” Johnson’s presence in the role was a long-overdue affirmation that Black girls deserve to see themselves in leading roles on Broadway.
Since her debut, Johnson has continued to advocate for more inclusivity in theater, using her platform to inspire future performers and encourage casting directors to embrace diversity.
Aisha Jackson: The First Black Anna in Frozen
Disney’s Frozen became a Broadway sensation in 2018, bringing the beloved animated film to life on stage. That same year, Aisha Jackson made history when she became the first Black actress to portray Princess Anna.
With all the gross negativity around the Ariel casting I just wanna share another beautiful black Disney Princess- Aisha Jackson as the stand-by Anna from Frozen Broadway! pic.twitter.com/uYkLR9JZm2
— rinks (@riinksu) July 4, 2019
From Understudy to Leading Lady
Jackson was originally cast as the understudy for Anna, but when she got the chance to step into the role, she made history. Her performance as the quirky, lovable princess proved that Disney’s stories could be just as magical with diverse casting.
A Moment That Inspired Fans Worldwide
For many theatergoers, seeing a Black woman play Anna was a powerful moment. Little Black girls who adored Frozen now had the chance to see a princess who looked like them—a testament to the importance of inclusive storytelling in theater.
Why Representation in Broadway Matters
The groundbreaking performances of Toni Braxton, Keke Palmer, Brittney Johnson, and Aisha Jackson are more than just historical moments—they represent a cultural shift in Broadway. These women didn’t just step into iconic roles; they redefined them, proving that Black actresses belong in leading roles traditionally dominated by white performers.
The Impact on Future Generations
When young Black girls see themselves represented on stage, it fosters confidence, ambition, and the belief that they, too, can be the hero of the story. Theater is meant to be a mirror of society, and these incredible women have helped ensure that Broadway is a more accurate, diverse reflection of the world we live in.
A Call for More Inclusivity
While these milestones are worth celebrating, they are just the beginning. There are still many barriers to break and many more stories to tell with diverse voices leading the way. Casting decisions like these should become the norm, not the exception.
Final Thoughts: A Standing Ovation for Black Women on Broadway
Broadway is at its best when it embraces diversity, talent, and fresh perspectives. Thanks to the incredible performances of Toni Braxton, Keke Palmer, Brittney Johnson, and Aisha Jackson, the stage is set for even more groundbreaking moments in the future.
Their achievements are a reminder that talent knows no racial boundaries—and that the magic of Broadway belongs to everyone.
Discover more from Where Is The Buzz | Breaking News, Entertainment, Exclusive Interviews & More
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
