Marcellus Wiley Faces Second Rape Allegation: Former NFL Star and Husband of RHOBH’s Annemarie Wiley Accused of Assaulting Two Women at Columbia University

Marcellus Wiley, the former NFL defensive end and husband of Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum Annemarie Wiley, is once again under fire. A second woman has come forward, accusing Wiley of rape during his time at Columbia University in the 1990s. The new allegation echoes a previous accusation from 2023, painting a disturbing picture of abuse, coercion, and institutional negligence.

As the scandal unfolds, questions about Wiley’s past, the role of Columbia University, and the response from those involved continue to mount.

A New Accusation Emerges

The latest accusation, filed in a civil lawsuit, claims that Wiley sexually assaulted the plaintiff in 1994 while they were both students at Columbia. According to court documents obtained by People, Wiley allegedly invited the woman to his dorm room under seemingly innocent circumstances. Once inside, the tone quickly shifted.

The woman claims Wiley began talking about sex, making her increasingly uncomfortable. Despite her repeated refusals and clear objections, Wiley allegedly grew agitated and aggressive. The lawsuit describes him as becoming physically overpowering, swinging her legs onto the bed and pinning her down. What followed was a harrowing account of sexual assault, with Wiley allegedly whispering disturbing phrases in her ear like, “Relax, enjoy it, stop crying, and stop fighting the feeling.”

The plaintiff says she was left traumatized and powerless, her cries for help ignored. But perhaps what’s most chilling is what happened next.

Allegations of Institutional Negligence

Following the alleged assault, the woman reported the incident to a Columbia University administrator, hoping for justice. Instead, she claims she was met with disbelief and outright hostility. According to the lawsuit, she was warned that pursuing her complaint would have severe consequences not for Wiley, but for her.

The administrator allegedly told her that filing a formal report would result in her becoming known as “the girl who destroyed a Black man’s NFL dream.” This stunning accusation sheds light on the university’s alleged complicity in protecting Wiley’s athletic career at the expense of the victim’s well-being.

The lawsuit seeks punitive damages from both Columbia University and Wiley, holding them accountable for the lasting emotional and psychological harm caused.

An Eerie Similarity: The 2023 Allegation

The latest accusation bears unsettling similarities to the 2023 lawsuit, in which another woman accused Wiley of raping her in her dorm room during his time at Columbia. The plaintiff in that case described a frighteningly similar scenario: an alleged pattern of coercion, intimidation, and sexual violence.

Wiley vehemently denied the 2023 allegation, even taking to YouTube to publicly defend himself. His response was as dismissive as it was performative, labeling the claims as “B.S.” and attempting to control the narrative by insisting that no intercourse occurred. His tone was casual, even smug, as he stated, “If you’re a virgin, I am not going to be your first.”

Despite his defiance, the details of the first accusation now feel even more damning in light of the new lawsuit. Two women, two eerily similar accounts, and one powerful man who continues to evade accountability.

Wiley’s Response Or Lack Thereof

While Wiley was quick to respond to the 2023 allegation, this time he’s remained noticeably silent. Neither he nor his legal team has issued a statement regarding the latest accusation. It’s a stark contrast from his previous bravado, raising questions about how Wiley plans to navigate the mounting legal and public scrutiny.

His wife, Annemarie Wiley, has also yet to comment. As a public figure in the Real Housewives franchise, her silence is deafening. The scandal threatens to cast a long shadow over both their reputations, especially as media attention intensifies.

Columbia University Under Fire

The lawsuits have also reignited criticism against Columbia University for its alleged failure to protect students from sexual violence. The accusations suggest a deeply ingrained culture of institutional protectionism, where star athletes were prioritized over survivors.

In a post-#MeToo era, these allegations feel all too familiar. Universities across the country have faced backlash for mishandling sexual assault cases, often shielding perpetrators to preserve their reputations. The lawsuits against Columbia serve as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of that negligence.

The Road Ahead

As the legal battle unfolds, the plaintiffs are seeking accountability not just from Wiley but from the institution that allegedly enabled his behavior. Both women are pursuing significant punitive damages, aiming to hold both the former athlete and the university responsible for the trauma they endured.

For Wiley, the court of public opinion is already in session. With the weight of two graphic and deeply troubling accusations against him, the days of playing the charismatic TV personality may be numbered. And as more details emerge, the facade of his pristine post-NFL image continues to crumble.

For the survivors, their bravery in coming forward is a testament to their resilience. They refuse to be silenced, demanding justice despite the odds stacked against them.

One thing is clear, this story is far from over.